What to Look Out for When Reviewing a Video Production Company’s Portfolio

Video Production Potfolio

The Safest Option Isn’t Always The Best Option


In the world of comms & marketing, there’s a frequent requirement to enlist the expertise of an external video production company or creative agency – it’s therefore common for people to stick with the same supplier, opting for a ‘safe’ choice with minimal risk. However, this approach can result in creativity becoming a bit stagnant. So, if you’re looking to inject some life into your marketing & comms, inviting creative agencies or video production companies to submit their portfolio is an excellent way to explore a range of new options.

When faced with the task of selecting a new agency or supplier, a multitude of factors come into play. Delving into their portfolio becomes a journey of subjective creativity, where definitively labelling something as ‘good’ becomes a challenge. It’s not just about saying, “That looks nice.” Factors such as alignment with the target audience, intricate messaging, and hidden budget constraints all play a vital role.

Evaluating portfolios can stir self-doubt. While you might think you know what you’re looking for, the need for a second opinion occasionally arises. Trust us; this uncertainty is a common experience, even from the creative perspective. So in this week’s blog, we’ve compiled a comprehensive list to help guide you in making informed decisions when selecting the right creative agency or video production company for your next project.

Factors to Consider When Selecting Potential Agencies or Video Production Companies


Quality of Work
Starting with the obvious, evaluate the portfolio’s production values. Consider the clarity of the image, resolution, sound quality (crucial for video production projects), and overall professionalism. Pay attention to the consistency of this quality across various projects.

Diversity and Range
Ensure your agency can cover a spectrum of subjects and creative approaches. Look for a diverse range of projects showcasing versatility in handling different styles, genres, or even industries.

Adherence to Brief
The accompanying paragraph to a case study or portfolio submission is a valuable opportunity. Use it to discuss how the work aligns with the client’s goals and objectives. Does it demonstrate an understanding of the client’s needs and vision?

Communication and Collaboration
Consider how well the portfolio reflects collaboration. Can the creative agency or video production company highlight the significance of effective communication between the client and the video production team?

Case Studies
Encourage your suppliers to provide detailed case studies alongside the usual montage of great work. These case studies give potential suppliers the chance to provide context, goals, challenges they faced and insights into their creative processes. Тhis can sometimes change your opinion of a supplier quite dramatically when you consider their final output against the challenges they faced.

Decoding the Elements of an Effective Video Production Portfolio


Client Testimonials
Gather a range of testimonials or references from previous clients if possible. This adds credibility and helps build trust, assuring you that the agency has the experience and knowledge to complete your briefs.

Innovation and Creativity
An effective portfolio should showcase unique approaches to storytelling or visual style, setting it apart from other video production companies, while maintaining high production levels.

Technical Expertise
Assess the technical skills showcased, including editing, cinematography, and post-production capabilities. If unsure, invite a discussion to understand the involved technicalities.

Industry Relevance
Consider the relevance of examples given to your industry. Does the portfolio demonstrate an understanding of industry trends and norms?

Does the portfolio show an ability to scale productions based on the client’s needs and budget? Are there examples of larger-scale projects, and are they necessary for your needs?

Budget Transparency
Encourage transparency regarding budget considerations in portfolio examples. It ensures realistic expectations and allows a discussion on balancing cost-effectiveness with high-quality production values and creativity.

Social Media Integration
Evaluate how the portfolio integrates with social media platforms. Explore variations in a single output and how it’s repurposed across various online channels.

Strategic Thinking
Look for evidence that the portfolio demonstrates strategic thinking in storytelling and visual communications. Are any projects part of a larger campaign, and how do they align with broader marketing or communication strategies?

Up-to-Date Technology
Ensure the portfolio utilises up-to-date technology. A visual and auditory check can reveal if the content matches contemporary techniques. If it feels old, questions should arise about the absence of newer work.

Hopefully, with our insights from the above two lists, you’re now equipped to navigate video production portfolios with confidence. Choosing the right creative agency or video production company is more than finding the most impressive work—it’s about aligning with a creative partner who understands and enhances your unique vision. Happy reviewing!

If you’d like to chat with us about an idea or project you may have, please do get in touch with our team at info@slateandmortar.com

Thinking about using an award winning production company for your next project?

Want to chat through a video or animation idea you may have?
Planning on using video or animation in your next campaign?

We’d love to hear from you. Get in touch today!